Burlington LOCKSMITHS
From the blog

Can a Locksmith Rekey Any Lock in Burlington?

You've just moved into a new home on Appleby Line, ended a tenancy, or maybe you've simply lost track of who has copies of your house key — and now you're wondering whether rekeying is all you need. It's a fair question, and the honest answer is: it depends entirely on what type of lock is on your door. Not every lock can be rekeyed, some are better off replaced outright, and a few situations call for a full lock installation service before a locksmith can do anything else.

Open 24 hours, 7 days a week · Licensed, bonded & insured

Burlington Locksmiths Service Team

Local locksmith team

Oct 17, 2026 10 min read

Can a Locksmith Rekey Any Lock in Burlington? — Burlington Locksmiths

You've just moved into a new home on Appleby Line, ended a tenancy, or maybe you've simply lost track of who has copies of your house key — and now you're wondering whether rekeying is all you need. It's a fair question, and the honest answer is: it depends entirely on what type of lock is on your door. Not every lock can be rekeyed, some are better off replaced outright, and a few situations call for a full lock installation service before a locksmith can do anything else.

This guide breaks down exactly which lock types qualify for rekeying, which ones don't, and how Burlington homeowners can make a smarter, more cost-effective decision — whether you're dealing with a standard door knob lock on a side entrance, a heavy-duty mortise lock on a heritage property near Old Lakeshore Road, or a modern smart lock on a newly built home in the Alton Village neighbourhood.

## What Rekeying Actually Does — and Why It's Not Always Enough

Rekeying a lock means a locksmith removes the cylinder, replaces the internal pin tumblers with a new set, and cuts a fresh key to match. The hardware stays exactly where it is — only the key that works it changes. This is genuinely useful when you want to ensure old keys no longer function without spending on new hardware. What it doesn't do is fix a worn mechanism, upgrade a weak lock grade, or add features your current lock simply wasn't built for. If your lock is damaged, poorly installed, or mechanically unreliable, rekeying it just gives you a fresh key to a lock that's already failing.

The process is also only possible if your lock has a rekeyable cylinder in the first place. Rekeying requires that replacement pins are manufactured for that specific lock model. Obscure imported hardware, very old lock mechanisms, and certain integrated smart lock designs don't have commercially available pin kits — meaning the only real option is a door lock installation with compatible new hardware.

## Which Locks Can Be Rekeyed — and Which Can't

The good news: most standard pin-tumbler locks found on Burlington homes can be rekeyed without issue. This includes popular brands like Schlage and Kwikset in their traditional deadbolt and door knob lock formats, as well as many commercial-grade cylindrical locks. These use a straightforward pin-tumbler cylinder that any experienced locksmith can repin efficiently. If you have one of these on your front or back door, rekeying is usually a fast, practical choice after a move or lost key situation.

The locks that can't be rekeyed — or where rekeying is inadvisable — fall into a few clear categories. First, mortise locks deserve special attention. A mortise lock is the larger, rectangular lock body that fits into a deep pocket (the 'mortise') cut into the door edge — common on older Burlington homes, heritage buildings near Brant Street, and many commercial properties. Mortise locks do have rekeyable cylinders, but those cylinders are a specific format (typically a removable oval or rim cylinder), and rekeying them correctly requires a locksmith with specific mortise lock experience. An inexperienced attempt can strip threads or misalign the tailpiece, causing the whole mechanism to fail. Second, certain smart locks — particularly those with fixed integrated key cylinders or keypad-only designs — have no rekeyable component at all. Replacing the lock entirely, which may mean a smart lock installation, is the only path forward. Third, wafer-tumbler locks (found on some older interior doors, filing cabinets, and cheap exterior hardware) often don't have commercially available rekey kits, and the low cost of the hardware usually makes replacement the sensible move anyway.

## Mortise Lock Rekeying and Replacement — What Burlington Homeowners Should Know

Mortise locks are among the most secure lock formats available, and they're more common across Burlington's older housing stock than many homeowners realize. If your home was built before the 1980s, there's a reasonable chance your front door uses a mortise lock body rather than a cylindrical deadbolt. These locks offer excellent resistance to forced entry because the bolt and latch are housed in a robust metal body embedded in the door itself — not just surface-mounted. That strength is worth preserving, which is why a qualified locksmith with mortise lock experience will always try to rekey the cylinder before recommending full replacement.

That said, if a mortise lock cylinder is heavily worn, if the lock body itself has cracked or corroded internals, or if the door mortise (the pocket itself) has been damaged from a previous forced-entry attempt or years of hard use, rekeying won't solve the underlying problem. In those cases, a proper lock installation — fitting a new mortise lock body correctly sized to the existing door pocket — is the right call. This is also common on commercial properties, where an emergency locksmith may be called after a break-in and needs to restore both security and function quickly. If you're unsure what type of lock you have, a quick call to our team will tell you what you're working with before you commit to any service. Call (289) 670-9821 — we answer 24/7 and can walk you through the options in plain language.

## When Replacement Is Smarter Than Rekeying — A Practical Decision Guide

There are several clear scenarios where a full door lock installation makes more sense than rekeying, even when rekeying is technically possible. If the lock is more than 10–15 years old and showing signs of wear — stiff operation, a loose cylinder, a bolt that doesn't extend fully — rekeying it simply delays the inevitable and leaves you with hardware that could fail at a bad moment. If you're upgrading from a basic door knob lock (which offers minimal forced-entry resistance on its own) to a deadbolt or a Grade 1 commercial-grade lock, you need a new lock installation regardless. And if you want to move to keyless entry — whether a keypad deadbolt or a full smart lock installation — rekeying your current cylinder isn't relevant; the new hardware replaces it entirely.

For Burlington homeowners looking at a smart door lock installation specifically, the decision usually comes down to compatibility with your existing door prep (the hole size and backset), whether you want Z-Wave or Bluetooth connectivity, and whether your door is solid wood, fiberglass, or steel. A skilled locksmith will assess your door before recommending any specific hardware, because a smart lock installed on an improperly prepped door will have alignment issues that no amount of software updates will fix. Commercial lock installation follows similar logic — a commercial locksmith evaluates door grade, traffic volume, and whether the application requires a mortise, cylindrical, or exit-device format before any hardware is ordered.

## What to Expect When You Call Burlington Locksmiths for a Rekey or Lock Installation Service

Whether you need a quick rekey after losing a key near Mapleview Mall, a mortise lock cylinder swap on an older home in the Palmer neighbourhood, or a full smart lock installation on a new build in Millcroft, the process starts the same way: our team confirms what you have, explains what's needed, and gives you a clear, up-front price before any work begins. The final quote depends on factors like the lock type and brand, the complexity of the installation or rekey, the time of day (we do offer 24/7 emergency locksmith service), any parts required, and travel distance — but you'll always know the number before we start.

Our mobile team handles a wide range of lock-related services across Burlington and the surrounding area, including: mortise lock rekeying, mortise lock replacement and installation, standard deadbolt rekeying, door knob lock rekeying and replacement, smart lock installation, smart door lock installation and pairing, keypad lock installation, door lock installation for new construction, door lock installation service for rental turnovers, commercial lock installation, commercial locksmith services for offices and retail, high-security cylinder upgrades, master key system setup, lock bumping and picking resistance assessments, exit device and push bar installation, padlock and hasp replacement, sliding door lock installation, garage door lock service, cabinet and storage lock replacement, mailbox lock rekeying, key duplication for rekeyable locks, lock installation service after a break-in, car lockout response, transponder key programming, and ignition lock cylinder service. If your situation isn't on this list, call us — chances are we can help. Reach us any time at (289) 670-9821.

## The Honest Answer: Ask Before You Assume

The most common mistake Burlington homeowners make is assuming rekeying is always the fastest or most economical path, or conversely, assuming they need a full replacement when a simple rekey would do the job. The right answer depends on the lock type, its age and condition, your security goals, and whether you're staying with keyed hardware or moving to a smart lock format. A door lock installation service that's done right the first time — whether that's a fresh mortise lock body, a Grade 1 deadbolt, or a smart lock installation near the entryway — will outlast a hasty decision made without proper assessment.

Burlington Locksmiths operates 24/7 across the Burlington area, so whether it's a scheduled rekey before a new tenant moves in or an emergency locksmith call at 2 a.m. after a lockout on New Street, our trained team is available. We carry the tools and parts for mortise lock work, standard cylindrical locks, and smart lock installations on every service call — no waiting for a second trip. Call (289) 670-9821 whenever you're ready, and we'll give you a straight answer and an exact price before anything is touched.

Frequently asked questions

Can a locksmith rekey a mortise lock, or does it always need to be replaced?+

A mortise lock can absolutely be rekeyed — but it requires a locksmith with specific mortise lock experience, because the cylinder format is different from a standard deadbolt. The oval or rim cylinder is removed, repinned to a new key, and reinstalled. The only reason a full replacement becomes necessary is if the lock body itself is mechanically damaged, if the mortise pocket in the door has been compromised, or if the cylinder model is no longer available with a rekey kit. When our team inspects the lock, we'll tell you honestly which category yours falls into.

Does a smart lock installation in Burlington require replacing my existing deadbolt?+

In most cases, yes — a smart lock installation replaces your existing deadbolt cylinder and thumb-turn assembly, or in some designs the entire lock body. Some smart locks are designed to retrofit over an existing deadbolt interior, but compatibility depends on your door's backset measurement, the thickness of the door, and the existing hole preparation. A skilled locksmith will check all of these before recommending a specific model. What you won't need in most Burlington homes is a full door mortise — standard smart locks use a cylindrical format that fits common door preps.

How do I know whether to rekey or replace the locks when I move into a new Burlington home?+

Rekeying makes sense if the existing locks are in good mechanical condition, less than 10 years old, and you're happy with their security grade. It's the right move if your only concern is that previous owners, contractors, or real estate agents may still have copies of the key. Replacement makes more sense if the locks are worn, if you want to upgrade the security grade (for example, adding a deadbolt where only a door knob lock existed), or if you want to switch to smart lock or keypad entry. A quick inspection by our team — which we can schedule any time, including same-day across Burlington — will confirm which option fits your specific doors.

What factors affect the price of a lock rekey or door lock installation service?+

Several things influence the final quote: the type of lock involved (a mortise lock rekey involves more steps than a standard deadbolt rekey), whether parts need to be sourced (new cylinders, pins, or full lock hardware), the time of day (our emergency locksmith service runs 24/7, and after-hours calls factor into the quote), and travel distance within the Burlington area. We always confirm an exact price up-front before any work begins — no surprise totals when the job is done.

Locked out or need a lock fixed? We are on the way.

(289) 670-9821